TopMyGrade

Home·Daily Problem

Daily Problem·Friday, 6 September 2024Back to today

Environmental ethics evaluation

GCSE · Religious Studies · AQA · 3.2.B.2 — The value of human and non-human life: dominion vs stewardship, environmental ethics, animal rights and the use of animals for food, scientific testing and pets

Question

(Q6) 'Religious people have a greater responsibility to care for the environment than non-religious people.' Evaluate this statement. (12 marks)

Mark scheme (levelled):

Level 4 (10–12) — Two contrasting views, supported, reasoned conclusion.

Agree: Religious people believe creation is God's gift — they are accountable stewards (khalifah; imago Dei). Laudato Si' makes care for creation a moral imperative. Destroying creation is an offence against God (Islamic tawhid). Religious communities can mobilise billions to act.

Disagree: Humanists have equally strong grounds — intergenerational justice, survival, love of nature. Dominion theology has historically encouraged exploitation. Non-religious environmentalists (David Attenborough) have arguably done more. Responsibility is universal, not religious.

Level 3 (7–9); Level 2 (4–6); Level 1 (1–3); 0.

12 marks · take your time before peeking.

Sign up to try the next 30 problems

Save your streak, mark answers against the spec, and build a daily revision habit. Free during public beta — no card, no auto-renew.

Generated by TopMyGrade AI · cross-check official sources before relying on the mark-scheme phrasing.