TopMyGrade

Home·Daily Problem

Daily Problem·Thursday, 10 October 2024Back to today

Limitations of single indicators

GCSE · Geography · CCEA · U2.CW.1 — Measuring development: GDP, HDI, GNI per capita; classification (HIC, MIC, LIC, NIC)

Question

CCEA Unit 2 — extended response

"GDP per capita is no longer a useful measure of development." Discuss this statement. [9 marks + 3 QWC]

Mark scheme — levels: L1 (1-3): one or two simple points; little or no example. e.g. "GDP only measures money". L2 (4-6): clear evaluation with at least one named example; some balance. L3 (7-9): detailed evaluation, named contrasting examples, balanced judgement reached.

Indicative content:

  • GDP measures economic output but ignores distribution, healthcare and education.
  • Examples: Saudi Arabia (high GNI, lower HDI than EU peers); South Africa (high GNI per capita but Gini coefficient ~0.63 → vast inequality).
  • However, GDP is a useful indicator: easy to compare, drives investment decisions, correlates with HDI overall.
  • Composite indicators (HDI, HPI) overcome GDP's blind spots by adding life expectancy and education.
  • Conclusion: GDP is necessary but insufficient — best used alongside composite measures. QWC (3): clear structure, accurate spelling/grammar, correct geographical terminology.

Total: 12 marks.

12 marks · take your time before peeking.

Sign up to try the next 30 problems

Save your streak, mark answers against the spec, and build a daily revision habit. Free during public beta — no card, no auto-renew.

Generated by TopMyGrade AI · cross-check official sources before relying on the mark-scheme phrasing.